Skip to main content

Why DO Bad Things Happen to Good People?

Her Take:

I’m excited about this week’s topic because I get to share the second-best life lesson I ever learned with you. Well, why don’t I give you the BEST life advice too, as long as I’m at it?

THE BEST was when I came home from school crying because people were bullying me for my weight. I looked up at my wise and impossibly ancient (he was maybe 40 at that time) father with tears in my eyes, yearning for guidance, and he gave me his sage counsel.
“Tell ‘em to kiss yer ass.”

I’m still not sure if he had been listening or if he thought I asked for the absolute quickest way to get suspended from Lutheran school, but I took his advice anyway, at least internally, and still do.
Now, the second-best life lesson came from my mother, and I hate to overshadow it with what is arguably my best story from real life ever, but it sets us up for what we really need to talk about now.

Flash forward to when I’m about 22 years old, and I find out that my Then-Father-in-Law has been diagnosed with the cancer that would eventually take him. Say what you will (oh, and I will) about my Ex, but he was adopted and raised by the most lovely people I’d ever met. Possibly the loveliest people in the known universe. His mother, Shiela, was a petite, charmingly dingy lady with an impossibly sweet nature and his father, Kermit (whose name was only one of the many awesome things about him) was brilliant, steady, and wise in all of the ways we genuinely need a father figure to be.

Sometime in the summer before I took my son and left my Ex, his father announced that the cancer that had been in remission since before I met him was back and, likely, incurable. It seemed so unfair, and I remember saying that to my mom. I literally remember asking her, “Why can bad things happen to good people while bad people seem to always go unpunished?”

And she said, very seriously, “We aren’t punished or rewarded for what we do here on earth, our reward is in heaven. Only God can reward or punish us.”

Notably, that was the first time I can remember Mom speaking theologically to me, and she made it count.

As usual, excellent advice was lost on a dumb kid’s brain because it took years for that to really sink in. There’s still this time in your life where everything is dramatic, right? And, don’t get me wrong, there were actually some pretty dramatic things that happened next.

If you’re lucky, though, you grow out of the phase of your and your friend’s lives where you find yourself riding around in a late-model used sedan - possibly someone’s mom’s car - trying to FIND someone else because YOU HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY TO THEIR FACE.

Eventually, like I said, if you’re lucky, you move past that part of your life where you need to cast yourself as some kind of avenging angel, intent on making wrongdoers cower in their keds, and realize that sometimes the world is cruddy. People make dumb choices, there are storms and disease, a lot of things feel wrong, and you’re either going to accept those things with some kind of zen or fight against it forever.
And I’m almost there.

There are still pockets of resistance left in me that explode occasionally. My 13-year-old self can’t help but cross her arms, screw up her face, stomp her foot and shout “BUT THAT’S NOT FAIR!” from time to time. Just ask the people I work with… and live with… and encounter casually… You know what, just ask anybody, and they’ll tell you that I still fight that fight, even if it’s a little more subtle. 

So how do I reconcile that? 

Want to know something weird? Knowing I had this topic to write about I’ve suddenly seen messages everywhere telling me exactly how I could tackle it if I wanted to. Someone on Facebook literally posted a meme that said “Instead of asking ‘Why did this happen?’ ask ‘What can I learn?’” Sure, those kinds of memes are less-than-a-dime-a-dozen. (They’re actually free if you don’t mind giving Mark Zukerberg all of your personal information.) and they are very nice, very surface advice to give. We should try to learn from the things that hurt us. 

But, you know what? Sometimes things just hurt. People hurt us, sometimes deliberately because their damagedness won’t let them do anything else. Men who have never smoked, drank, or even cursed meet their moment of grace because cancer has to take them. 

Things we can’t control and don’t make sense and tear at our souls in a way that is probably going to scar us forever happen. 

The truth is that there sometimes isn’t a lesson, not really. Sure,  maybe you decide to say ‘I love You.’ more often or appreciate every moment and, hey, do ALL of that, but we can - probably should - learn those things without the world falling down around our ears. Maybe it’s more accurate to say that sometimes the only lesson is that good things happen to bad people too and we have to be ok knowing that.

Ugh. I hate leaving you on that note, so let me give you one more life lesson courtesy of my Mom, ok?

Flash forward now to about 5 years ago and I have to tell my mom some news that I know is going to change things for our family forever. I was scared to death about the future and even more afraid that, once she knew, she’d never forgive me for what I had to tell her. She had a hard time understanding what I was saying because I was crying and, of course, that meant I had to repeat words that felt, at the time, like the end of the world, several times. 

When I finally got the words all out and she finally knew what they all meant, there was a long silence on the phone. Almost so long that I thought she had hung up.
Then she said, “It’s going to be okay.”

I was furious. 
“How can you say that! Do you even understand what this all means???”

“Suzanne.”, she said calmly,”It’s going to be okay because it just is. Think of all we’ve been through, and no matter what happens, we make it okay because we have to.”


So there you go: Bad things happen to good people and we make it okay, because we have to. 

His Take: 

Full disclosure, I’m the one who wanted this subject and I’m the one who can’t fricking write about it to save my life. This is the third time I’ve written this piece, the first two were both over 600 words in length. At this point I’ve got no choice but to be short and sweet and I apologize in advance. Why do good things happen to bad people? Because, well, shit happens. Be assured that good thing DO happen to GOOD people, but it seems like a lot of people that are generally, really despicable human beings seem to always fall ass over elbows into money, noteariaty, prosperity, and the like while the rest of the people have to scrape and claw and go without. I think the answer is really complex, but when you boil it down, it comes down to this: Good people aren’t willing to do the things that bad people do to get the things that bad people do. I assure you, I’m far from perfect and I’m no angel, but there’s stuff that people I know have done to get ahead that would turn your shit white. Embezzlement, cheating on taxes, illegally employing people, those are the “nicest” ones I’ll mention, because quite honestly, there are other things that I’ve witnessed or been told that is too vile to write on the internet. Let that sink in for a minute: too. Vile. To. Write. On. The . Internet. 

So, to the good people out there who’re reading this, I want you to join me in a challenge. I believe that honesty, hard work, determination, kindness, being genuine with yourself and others can kick the crap outta lying, cheating and stealing. Now, I want to show THEM that it does. If you’re inclined, join me in putting our noses to the grindstone and being successful GOOD people., Our action will speak louder than our words ever can. So put you’re big pants on, dig in and get to work. We’re gonna kick their asses!!!....in a nice, polite, way. 
x

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Something Positive

Her Take: The scene that follows describes me embroiled in a confrontation with my arch-enemy.  This is a very dramatic scene, so please read it that way. If you feel the urge to exclaim something suitable for this mood or draw the back of your hand to your forehead in a gesture of utter dismay, feel free to do so. Just don’t bite your fingernails, that’s gross.  I knew at the beginning of last week I was going to have to write something positive for this blog entry, and now here I sit. Laptop open, fingers paused mid-word, essentially useless.  Enemy mine, I confront you.  I even told myself and my co-blogger that sure, I wasn’t feeling too many warm and fuzzy things yet but if something didn’t come to mind, I would just have to create something positive to talk about. Admittedly, up to that point, I had been spending most of my free time wallowing in self pity. (Hey, that’s not a one-and-done kind of thing, you really have to set aside time to rumi...

Four Things That Will Change the World

It turns out, much to our chagrin, that we are  "Kids these days"-years-old.  Yes, we have a lot of thoughts on what's wrong with the world, but instead of just griping about them to each other, this week we're happy to present our ideas on what we could all do to make the world better.  His Take:  Fixing the world seems hard, but I have it nailed down to just 4 easy steps. Why 4? 'Cause that’s the number that Sue told me I had. Challenge accepted!!  #1)Social Media Wipeout- Social Media is VERY useful. You can catch up with old friends or new friends, you can see what’s going on in their lives, you can check out movie or book reviews from people that aren’t “professional” reviewers. The possibilities are endless. The problem is..the possibilities are endless. For every person that says “Hey, that’s a great new car you got!” there’s one that says “I can’t believe you bought that piece of dogshit!”. Unfortunately, that’s just the beginning. I’m not ...

Her Take, October 2020

Ok, here’s the deal: we started this blog because we like to write. No, wait, it’s more than that. we need to write. Not in a melodramatic-tortured-artist kind of way (I wish) but in a we-decided-that-we-both-needed-to-address-our-mental-health kind of way. It’s the challenge, the honesty, and the ability to say what we want to say when we want to say it that keeps bringing us back to write more. And when we walk away, in no small part because you come here and read it, we feel better. Healthier.  And we did a good job of it for a long time. Sure, one of us (Me) was constantly late with their blog and one of us (also me) will suggest a topic and then get mad and throw a fit about how stupid the topic is. Hey, we know that we (I) have our issues to work out. But it’s good, right? We write a thing, you read a thing and.. Hey, with all of the love in the world, we started writing before anyone was reading so I there’s a chance we’d keep going if you stopped.  Well, I thought so a...